Design Engineering

Canada running out of time to buy F-35 fighter jets

Review warns government that cost of replacing Canada's CF 18s is quickly rising beyond F-35 purchase budget.

December 10, 2014   by The Canadian Press

12-dec-f-35-fiscal-cliff-360OTTAWA — The Harper government is being warned that there’s increasingly less wiggle room in its $9 billion budget envelope, if it intends to buy the F-35 stealth fighter.

On Wednesday, the public works secretariat overseeing the replacement of the country’s existing CF-18s released its annual assessment of the program, which has been on hold for two years.

The independent review says the lifetime cost of owning the radar-evading jet has edged back up to $45.8 billion over 40 years.

That figure includes the cost of buying 65 jets, as well as maintaining and operating them over their entire service life.


After a scathing auditor general’s report accused National Defence and public works of low-balling the cost and not doing their homework, the Conservatives put the program on hold and froze the purchase budget at $9 billion.

But the review released Wednesday warned that time and various economic factors are eating away at the cushion of contingency funds, which is now estimated at just $76 million.

Even a slight variance in inflation or the exchange rate could blow the budget envelope.

Experts at the accounting firm of Grant Thornton, which conducted the review, say the project remains affordable within the existing framework and suggest that if the contingency gets chewed up, the shortfall “could be met by buying fewer aircraft.”

But the analysis notes that even over the long term, there are risks because in order to meet the maintenance costs the F-35 would have to be flown much less than the current fleet.

“This estimate uses a planned yearly flying rate of 11,700 hours — approximately 20 per cent less than the currently planned CF-18 yearly flying rate — or 15 hours per month per aircraft,” said the report.

The analysis suggests, if the government decides, to continue with the program, it could start buying the planes in 2020 with a few aircraft arriving each year until the CF-18s are retired in 2025.

The federal cabinet received an overall analysis of what options are out there to replace the current fleet, which is over 30 years old, but it has yet to make a decision whether to continue — or hold an open competition.

There was a Pentagon report last month that stated Canada wanted to buy four F-35s in the 2015-16 budget year and had asked the U.S. Air Force to make arrangements, but the notion was shot down by senior government officials.

The F-35 has been the subject of cost overruns and delays for years and the analysis suggests that hurdles, mostly in the plane’s advanced systems remain a problem.

“Software continues to be the most challenging technical risk to the F-35 program,” said the report. “Software build delays and limitations in delivered software capabilities have caused delays in mission system testing, putting at risk the schedule for achieving initial operating capability.”

© 2014 The Canadian Press

Print this page

Related Stories

1 Comment » for Canada running out of time to buy F-35 fighter jets
  1. David Koss says:

    The sooner Canada backs away completely from the F-35 the better. The sooner Canada stops listening to the nonsensical claims of the maker of the F-35 the better. F-35 “stealth” designed in the 1990s is now obsolete and easily detected by new systems both radar and heat. Many of the “advanced systems” in the F-35 are also obsolete in a program 8 years behind schedule and $160 billion over budget . A good example of how F-35’s competition is improving is the UK made Selex GaN AESA radar and infra red system in the new improved Saab Gripen, the Gripen E. It is a generation ahead of the system in F-35 in the air to air role. A jet that will cost 1/2 as much as F-35 and fly for nearly 1/4 the cost yet a capable better performing (faster, more agile and better range, reliable, minimal ground support) and easier to upgrade platform as systems evolve over time. Gripen already is cleared to carry the best air to air missile in the world, the ramjet Meteor. A missile that cannot fit in the F-35 weapons bay. The F-35 sales success is it’s marketing and not the product itself. Time for a fair and open fighter tender process to replace the trusty CF-18.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *